Coleman v. Morgan Stanley

Financier Ronald Perelman wins $604 million, with a request for punitive damages still to come, against Morgan Stanley on claims that the Wall Street firm defrauded him seven years ago when he sold camping equipment maker Coleman to Sunbeam Corp., a Morgan client. (Bloomberg/New York Times/AP). The unexpectedly large verdict came after the Florida state […]

Financier Ronald Perelman wins $604 million, with a request for punitive damages still to come, against Morgan Stanley on claims that the Wall Street firm defrauded him seven years ago when he sold camping equipment maker Coleman to Sunbeam Corp., a Morgan client. (Bloomberg/New York Times/AP). The unexpectedly large verdict came after the Florida state judge presiding over the case blasted Morgan and its law firm for not responding in a forthcoming way to requests for discovery of electronically stored records, and instructed the jury to infer that the withheld documents demonstrated fraud. Blog commentary: Monica Bay, Francis Pileggi, Lisa Stone (and earlier), Litigation Support Guy (and again), Tom Kirkendall (and earlier), Really Think. More: jury votes $850 million in punitive damages (Jill Barton, “Perelman Wins $1.4 Billion Total in Suit Against Morgan Stanley”, AP/Law.com, May 19); Tom Kirkendall comments (May 18). Updates Dec. 17: Morgan Stanley files appeal; Mar. 22, 2007: appeals court overturns verdict.

3 Comments

  • PERELMAN GETS $604.3 MILLION

    Matthew McCarrick at Litigation IT Solutions tipped us off to the jury verdict handed down just hours ago, awarding billionaire financier Ron Perelman $604.3 million in compensatory damages. See the story in BusinessWeek here. Morgan Stanley’s retail b…

  • Zealous representation: a (wordy) response to Evan Schaeffer

    Evan Schaeffer has criticized the tone of a post I wrote this weekend, and deserves a response. But I need to preface it with a true story about the litigation decisions an attorney faces….

  • Update: Morgan Stanley $1.5 billion verdict

    The financial services firm has now filed its appeal of the mega-verdict (see May 18) awarded in a Florida court to billionaire financier Ron Perelman, who sued Morgan over its role in a 1998 deal…