The irrationality of non-economic damages

by Ted Frank on April 2, 2006

Unlawfully detained for fourteen years because of a crime you didn’t commit? $14.5 million in damages.

Unlawfully detained for fourteen minutes because of a crime you didn’t commit? $1.2 million in damages, plus potential punitives.

If the fairness of a justice system can be evaluated by whether it treats like cases alike, the status quo fails. (”Jury returns $14.5 million verdict against city”, AP, Mar. 30; Mark Rice, “Jury awards woman $1.2M”, Columbus Ledger-Enquirer, Apr. 1).

Related posts

{ 1 comment }

1 Kent 04.02.06 at 4:31 pm

That works out to about $5 million an hour. I don’t know anyone whose time is anywhere close to that valuable — not even Bill Gates. And these aren’t even the punitive damages.

Utterly ridiculous.

Please post again when this award is reduced on appeal.

Comments on this entry are closed.