“We were getting people with 60 hours of college credit who were reading at a third-grade level. What do you think you’ll get if you have no screening process?”

by Ted Frank on January 6, 2010

So asks Charlie Roberts, who ran the testing division for the Chicago Police Department from 1995 to 1999, upon learning that the city is simply going to give up on testing because of the threat of lawsuits. (Fran Spielman and Frank Main, “Police may scrap entrance exam”, Chicago Sun-Times, Jan. 6.) The problem is exacerbated by the EEOC’s Four-Fifths Rule—of dubious constitutionality after Ricci—which holds that any selection process that results in a selection rate for any race, sex, or ethnic group less than four-fifths of the most successful group is “adverse impact” that “constitutes discrimination unless justified.” 41 CFR § 60-3.

{ 1 trackback }

Simple Justice
01.07.10 at 7:45 am


1 GregS 01.07.10 at 12:08 pm

So in an age where the police are tasked with enforcing ever more complicated and arcane laws, we think it’s unfair to expect them to be able to read above the third grade level?

2 William Nuesslein 01.07.10 at 12:30 pm

“There’s a legal limit to the snow here,
in Camelot”
but such a limit on snow in Chicago would be considered foolish.

I agree with the eliminating the tests, because tests can not be valid and race-neutral at the same time, and that is what the law requires.

3 Jane 01.07.10 at 12:49 pm

Illiterate cops? That’s about all they can hire in Jackson, Mississippi.

4 Todd Rogers 01.07.10 at 1:32 pm

This is a dream come true for plaintiff attorneys. Coerce law-enforcement in to hiring crap-for-brains rookies thereby creating a nice stream of civil rights lawsuits. What could possibly be wrong with this bright idea?

5 jkoerner 01.08.10 at 9:32 am

This is why we should appeal outdated civil rights laws. They cause more trouble than they are worth.

Comments on this entry are closed.