Hiccup Girl lawyer may blame Tourette’s

by Walter Olson on October 28, 2010

Annals of unusual criminal defenses: the lawyer defending Hiccup Girl Jennifer Mee on murder charges says he may blame her actions on Tourette’s Syndrome, a medical condition not ordinarily linked to violence or criminality. [CBS News/WFOR/AP, Lowering the Bar]


1 Malcolm Smith 10.28.10 at 12:55 am

A person who commits a crime because of a medical condition should not be punished. However, he/she is still a danger to society, and should be locked away for the sake of the rest of us.

2 David Schwartz 10.28.10 at 4:10 am

When you can figure out how to lock people away without punishing them, let us know.

3 Bob Lipton 10.28.10 at 7:12 am

By legislation, of course. One need simply title the bill “The Locking People Away Without Punishing Them Act” and hey presto, it go up there with all the other laws we make fun of here.


4 John Burgess 10.28.10 at 8:34 am

Or you could change the phrase, ‘Locking People Away’ to ‘Sending on an All Expenses Paid Holiday for Life’.

5 Mark Phaedrus 10.28.10 at 11:02 am

Well, I guess that if there’s a videotape that makes it utterly clear that your client did it, and your client refuses to plead guilty, then you’ve gotta come up with something.

6 John Burgess 10.28.10 at 11:53 am

Has anyone seen a response from any of the Tourette’s advocacy groups? I’m sure they’re thrilled to the core with this theory of defense.

7 Reformed Republican 10.28.10 at 1:15 pm

She just happened to be holding a gun, and pointing it at the victim, when she was afflicted by a tic. It was completely involuntary.

8 Walter Olson 10.28.10 at 1:19 pm

Just to be clear, of course, that’s a joke; police think one of the others present most likely pulled the trigger. She’s up on a felony murder rap for allegedly luring the victim to a robbery that then turned lethal.

9 Nobody Special 10.28.10 at 9:08 pm

Or you could change the phrase, ‘Locking People Away’ to ‘Sending on an All Expenses Paid Holiday for Life’.

Or you could call the bill the “Secure Provision of Free Healthcare Act”

10 Frank 10.29.10 at 9:06 am

re: locking people away without punishment.

Civil commitment for life for sex offenders after they have completed their punitive sentences is claime to be non-punitive.

Comments on this entry are closed.