Speech criticizing lawsuit = “retaliation”

by Walter Olson on November 14, 2011

Brushing off First Amendment objections, a federal court has ruled that a union can be sued for “retaliation” after it defended itself in print against a lawsuit by two of its members. [Eugene Volokh]

{ 1 comment }

1 Hugo S. Cunningham 11.14.11 at 10:12 pm

In an ideal world, the same jury would hear the “retaliation” suit as heard the original discrimination and failure-to-represent suits. If they agreed that the underlying discrimination claim was frivolous, they would be inclined to reject a lawsuit against truthful speech. If they thought the discrimination claim had merit, however, they might find against the article, as an attempt to mobilize unjustified intimidation.

Comments on this entry are closed.