Beverly Hills yoga master Bikram Choudhury copyrighted a series of 26 yoga postures, exercises, breathing techniques and dialogues and is now seeking to enforce his intellectual property in them. His series of legal actions has roused controversy among yoga buffs, some of whom “say that yoga is a 5,000-year- old tradition that cannot be owned” and are fighting back in court. (Julian Guthrie, “Yogis go to court over poses”, San Francisco Chronicle, Feb. 5; “Yoga master’s lawsuit? Bad karma”, Reuters/CNN, Feb. 9; Martin Hodgson and agencies, “New twist to yoga positions as guru sues”, The Guardian (UK), Feb. 9). For efforts to enforce intellectual property in quilt designs, see Dec. 18-19, 2000. Update Apr. 17, 2005: judge rules Choudhury’s claims not necessarily barred under copyright law.
Archive for February, 2004
Citibank class action: another two cents
St. Petersburg Times has an article quoting this site’s letters comment section at some length, and also quoting yours truly. (Stephen Nohlgren, “Jingly justice or puny payoff?”, Feb. 9). The case has also been examined recently in Forbes (William Baldwin, “Lawyers 1, Consumers 0”, Feb. 16); Chuck Shepherd’s News of the Weird; and the Salt Lake Tribune (Paul Rolly and JoAnn Jacobsen-Wells, Jan. 14: Salt Lake City resident Bob Cole got a check for two cents)(more on class actions).
Runaway Alabama jury
For about five years, insurance agent James Richard Perry kept collecting $50 monthly premiums from Carolyn Whittaker for a $25000 life insurance policy that had lapsed. She sued Mr. Parry, of course, after she learned of the deception, but also sued the insurance company, Southwestern Life, for failing to investigate the agent’s past before hiring him. The jury awarded twenty million dollars in compensatory damages–and then topped that off with $1.6 billion in punitives. Alabama state law will reduce the punitive damages award to “only” sixty million, but the underlying “compensatory” damages award is beyond unreasonable–as is the idea of punitive damages against the life insurance company for what is, at worst, negligence that cost Ms. Whittaker a few thousand dollars. (AP, Feb. 6; “Macon County Woman Wins Billions [sic] In Insurance Case”, WSFA, Feb. 6).
Tribe: that Crayola factory is ours
The latest land claim assertion, by the Delaware Nation, is openly meant to be traded off for casino rights. The law firm of Cozen & O’Connor is representing the tribe in the action, which targets not only crayon-maker Binney & Smith but 19 hapless homeowners as well as a couple of small businesses and several layers of Pennsylvania government. We wrote about Indian land claim litigation a year and a half ago. (Shannon P. Duffy, “Indian Tribe Sues Over Pennsylvania Land”, The Legal Intelligencer, Jan. 20). Update: court dismissed case in late 2004 (PDF).
Super Bowl Kerfuffle II
Erstwhile defender of Madison County legal practice Evan Schaeffer attacks the recent lawsuit over Janet Jackson’s Super Bowl halftime show. (“Notes from the (Legal) Underground” blog, Feb. 8). Mr. Schaeffer’s legal analysis is this instance is impeccable — and ironic.
Radio Shack receipt suit
A customer from the Long Island suburb Wyandanch had her address entered into a Radio Shack computer by a prankster under her town’s nickname “Crimedanch.” Tanisha Torres, who acknowledges that she’s heard other people use the nickname, was so “embarrassed, flustered and shamed” that, after having that address printed out on a Radio Shack receipt on several occasions, she ran to a lawyer, Andrew Siben, who has sued the retail chain. (Robin Topping, “No Writing Off This Receipt”, Newsday, Feb. 4) (via Obscure Store). We think Mr. Siben is suffering from a failure of imagination: if Radio Shack has such potency that it can force a customer to shop there again and again even as it was repeatedly causing her such emotional distress, then it must have a degree of market power that potentially violates the antitrust laws.
Siben was previously quoted by Newsday lamenting that a spate of good weather had reduced his office’s workload of slip-and-fall cases. (A.J. Carter, “A Weather-Related Slowdown”, Jul. 29, 2002). Siben made his first mark in this space for an $80,000 settlement in a $4 million suit against the Upper Room Tabernacle Church, explaining to the New York Post that the plaintiff “was caused to fall by the Holy Spirit but unfortunately there was no-one there to catch her when she fell.” (Feb. 11-12, 2002; “Worshipper’s Holy Spirit Fall Nets Her $80,000 From Church”, New York Post, Feb. 2, 2002). Siben also represented Edwin Devito in his $5 million suit against American Airlines; Devito claims he was “knocked to the floor” (but not hospitalized) and suffered nightmares when a jet engine from Flight 587 crashed near where he was working. (AP, Sep. 9, 2002).
Answering machine suit dismissed
A gentleman who left a message on rap star Snoop Dogg’s answering machine sued when the message ended up as part of a “song.” A Los Angeles Superior Court judge ruled that the plaintiff had no expectation of privacy when he left the message. (“LA judge dismisses suit against rapper over phone message”, AP, Jan. 31) (via SoCalLawBlog).
(Full disclosure: I briefly represented a co-defendant of Death Row Records in a civil lawsuit. Don’t ask.)
Super Bowl Kerfuffle
By popular demand: “Terri Carlin wants to make Janet Jackson’s bare breast into a federal case.” (“Tenn. Woman Files Suit Over Super Bowl”, AP, Feb. 5; Randy Kenner, “State of undress causes distress”, Knoxville News-Sentinel, Feb. 5; complaint). See updates Feb. 8, Feb. 14 (case withdrawn); May 28 (another case loses).
Posting lull
Postings from me will likely be sparse over the next few days as I’m on the road: the International Association of Defense Counsel has invited me to speak at their midyear meeting in Orlando. Next week there’ll be more travel, including a speech next Wednesday at a conference put on by the Center for Constructive Alternatives at Hillsdale College in Michigan. There’s more ahead, including two New York City events later this month (details to come); I’ve also agreed to be a participant in the University of Colorado at Boulder’s 56th Conference on World Affairs this Apr. 5-9. If you’re an event sponsor interested in booking an appearance, you can email me directly through this site or contact the Manhattan Institute at 212-599-7000.
From schoolhouse to courthouse
Latest newspaper account surveying the many, many ways schools get sued these days. This one is from the Tampa Bay area. (Melanie Ave, “Lawsuits drain school dollars”, St. Petersburg Times, Feb. 2)