George Will, Lynne Cheney, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Rudolph Giuliani, and Bob Barr are all on record opposing this wretched would-be Constitutional amendment, and they’re right. See Faith Bremner, “Conservatives opposing marriage amendment”, Gannett News Service/The Coloradoan, Dec. 11, 2003. For our earlier posts on the subject, see Feb. 20 and Feb. 25. For a comeback to the ripely absurd “FMA is needed to bolster fertility rates” argument, see Jacob Levy, Volokh Conspiracy, (Jul. 9); for some ribbing of social conservatives who seem determined to borrow the “precautionary principle” from enviro absolutists for this occasion, see Jane Galt’s co-blogger “Mindles H. Dreck” (Jul. 8, Jul. 9). “As for the gay Republicans whose votes Mr. Bush might then lose, Mr. Weyrich [Paul Weyrich, prominent in the Washington religious right] wrote, ‘Good riddance.'” (Carl Hulse and David D. Kirkpatrick, “Senate Braces Itself for Fight on Gay Marriage”, New York Times, Jul. 9). And the same kind sentiments to you, sir!
More: And the Chicago Tribune (Jul. 13), and the Wall Street Journal, and Richard Epstein…. Update Jul. 14: defeated 48-50 on procedural vote. Yet more: Dale Carpenter (U. of Minn. Law School), “The Federal Marriage Amendment: Unnecessary, Anti-federalist, and Anti-democratic”, Cato Institute White Papers, Sept. 23; Rep. Christopher Cox (R-Calif.), “The Marriage Amendment Is a Terrible Idea”, Wall Street Journal, Sept. 28 ($).
5 Comments
Two FMA Thoughts
Much is being blogged about the decline and fall of the Federal Marriage Amendment (best overview I’ve seen is at Overlawyered.com).
Two quick additional observations…
Senate Debating Marriage Amendment
As you likely know, the US Senate has been debating the Federal Marriage Amendment and is expected to vote in a few days. Overlawyered.com reviews the conservative opposition to the measure and says: “As for the gay Republicans whose votes…
More On The Marriage Amendment
TalkLeft is all too frequently a repository of silly arguments. Consider this reaction to the proposed Federal Marriage Amendment:Hey, Mr….
More On The Marriage Amendment
TalkLeft is all too frequently a repository of silly arguments. Consider this reaction to the proposed Federal Marriage Amendment:Hey, Mr….
in re paul m. (marriage, too)
“dice” from paul m .