Edward Fagan’s tsunami lawsuit

Nineteen German and Austrian tourists are filing a lawsuit against the government of Thailand and the French hotel chain Accor over the Indian Ocean tsunami. Naturally, the lawsuit has been filed in New York. Another defendant is the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration; plaintiffs complain that NOAA’s Pacific Tsunami Warning System failed to issue a […]

Nineteen German and Austrian tourists are filing a lawsuit against the government of Thailand and the French hotel chain Accor over the Indian Ocean tsunami. Naturally, the lawsuit has been filed in New York. Another defendant is the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration; plaintiffs complain that NOAA’s Pacific Tsunami Warning System failed to issue a warning for a tsunami in a completely different ocean. (Aside from the fact that NOAA owes no duty to vacationing Germans in Thailand, NOAA did try to notify other countries of the tsunami potential of the earthquake.) The suits against NOAA and Thailand in a US court are frivolous in the narrowest sense of the word, and will likely be quickly dismissed; Accor will probably have to spend some time and money if it can’t get out on jurisdictional grounds. Edward Fagan (Feb. 5, Aug. 13, Apr. 2, Aug. 8, 2003 and links therein) is the attorney; press coverage uncritically repeats the claim that he is “best known for filing lawsuits seeking reparations for Holocaust victims,” a self-promotion others disagree with. (Jean-Michel Stoullig, AFP/Wash. Times, Feb. 15; cf. also AP, Feb. 13; hat tip to reader D.C.). I’m curious: does Fagan sue his local news weather department if he gets wet because of an unanticipated rainstorm?

At least Fagan isn’t claiming that his lawsuit will stop tsunamis. This site does make that claim for its “lawsuit”; it’s possible that it’s a tongue-in-cheek art project, but the smart money is betting that it’s the work of a full-fledged self-parodying moonbat. It’s not clear if there’s an actual lawsuit; lawsuits by the deranged tend to be more entertaining than socially problematic, except for district court judges unfortunate enough to be in the Ninth Circuit.

7 Comments

  • How slimy can a lawyer get?

    Overlawyered has a story about a lawyer representing a group of German and Austrian tourist suing the government of Thailand, a hotel chain, and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Association.

    Perhaps when this lawsuit gets dismissed as frivolou…

  • Tsunami lawsuit

    Filed on Friday in a New York court, and subjected to critical scrutiny here. See Overlawyered, Feb. 16….

  • Tsunami Lawsuit

    Ed Fagan filed a suit in New York Friday, seeking damages against the Pacific Tsunami Warning Center for failing to warn the world about December’s tsunami, 7000 miles away and i…

  • Tsunami lawsuit

    Filed on Friday in a New York court, and subjected to critical scrutiny here. See Overlawyered, Feb. 16…..

  • Tsunami lawsuit

    Filed on Friday in a New York court, and subjected to critical scrutiny here. See Overlawyered, Feb. 16….

  • we shift our feet

    winter sun lifting his round face to catch it

  • The scum of the Earth, and some nutters.

    Take out the lawyers and the other ill-fitting trappings of civilisation, and they’re just plundering the bodies.