Suits against cruise lines by passengers who get sick on board are bringing the courts quite a bit of business at the moment, but the lawsuit against Holland America Line by 81-year-old Bernice Oltman and her son, Jack Oltman, goes further. “The Oltmans said they suffered from a gastrointestinal illness, and also saw crew members eating directly from buffet platters. ‘During the scheduled stop in Ecuador, Jack Oltman noticed some crew members openly associating with prostitutes,’ the lawsuit said.” (There was an overflowed toilet, too.) “The Oltmans said they expected to be compensated by Holland America for pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of earnings, legal fees and medical expenses, including a colonoscopy and hemorrhoid surgery, the lawsuit said.” (“Cruise Line Sued for ‘Unsanitary’ Cruise”, Reuters, Apr. 1). “Scandalous” pleadings, as described in legal authorities such as Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12, include those which serve to heap disrepute on the opponent without advancing any colorable claim; presumably the Oltmans’ attorney is prepared to demonstrate a convincing link between the alleged tarts and the alleged torts.

Filed under: emotional distress, procedure