“A good sign that Mississippi has passed fair tort reform is Ralph Nader not liking it.”
— Pete Smith, spokesman for Governor Haley Barbour.
(Lynda Edwards, AP, Jun. 18; previous coverage on Mississippi on Jun. 11 and Nader Mar. 1).
Plea bargaining
Nearly 95 percent of felony convictions result from plea bargains rather than trial, and acclaimed documentary-maker Ofra Bikel scrutinizes the process in a PBS “Frontline” show that aired last night (“The Plea”, Jun. 17). Last year (Fall 2003) the Cato Institute’s Regulation magazine published pro and con articles on the practice (Timothy Lynch, “The Case Against Plea Bargaining” (PDF); Timothy Sandefur, “In Defense of Plea Bargaining” (PDF)).
John O’Quinn for Texas governor?
The Houston-based mass tort specialist, who has long played a prominent role in these columns for his exploits in asbestos, tobacco, silicone implants and most recently fen-phen (Apr. 28, Feb. 26 and many more), is now being talked of by activists as a potential Democratic candidate for governor of the Lone Star State. (W. Gardner Selby, “Democrats appear to be in no rush to challenge Perry for governorship”, San Antonio Express-News, Jun. 15). One factor helpful to him: last fall (see GregsOpinion.com, Oct. 25) Texas Democrats elected as their chairman San Marcos attorney Charles Soechting, who happens to practice at none other than the law firm of O’Quinn, Laminack & Pirtle.
Massachusetts tobacco fees: “Greed on Trial”
“The question before the jurors was not whether legal fees amounting to $7,700 an hour were ‘unreasonable.’ It was whether the lawyer-plaintiffs should get $1.3 billion more.” Detailed account of tobacco-fee buccaneering and the resulting courtroom antics (complete with “trained-seal” expert witnesses) in one state. When contemplating the tobacco crusade, the chief of litigation at Brown Rudnick said, “I had dollar signs in my eyes, even back at that early stage. And I know that they were large dollar signs.” (Alex Beam, The Atlantic, Jun.). For our coverage of Massachusetts tobacco fees, see Nov. 4 and links from there.
Baron to co-chair Kerry’s “Victory ’04”
Almost enough to make you want to vote for Bush: Dallas mass tort operator Fred Baron, poster boy for legal ethics and co-finance chairman of John Edwards’ presidential campaign (see Feb. 19), has been named co-chairman of Kerry Victory ’04, a joint effort by the Democratic National Committee and the campaign of presumptive nominee Kerry. “Baron says his contacts with contributors who can write big checks which, no doubt, include high-profile Texas plaintiffs lawyers were, in part, responsible for him getting the new post.” (“Texas Lawyer With Edwards Ties Joins Kerry Team”, Texas Lawyer/New York Lawyer, Jun. 2). More: detailed article on how Kerry, whose “voting record shows strong support for the plaintiffs bar”, has inherited the support of John Edwards’ trial-lawyer-based fund-raising machine (Lily Henning, “Edwards’ Army Recruited for Kerry Cash Push”, Legal Times, Jun. 18). Includes quotes from Washington mass tort attorney John Coale (“Kerry has just about a perfect record on issues that interest lawyers and trial lawyers,”) and our friend Lester Brickman. What if Kerry names Edwards as his v.p. pick? “If he’s on the ticket, you can reasonably predict that the amount of giving from trial lawyers will double or triple,” Brickman says. “They will unzip their wallets like they never had before. This would be unprecedented.” Yet more: the AP is on the story (Sharon Theimer, “Trial lawyers boost Kerry’s campaign effort”, AP/Houston Chronicle, Jun. 20)
Double-counting OK in N.Y. child support formulas
Despite objections that it is institutionalizing “double dipping”, New York’s highest court has given its assent to a manifestly unfair practice in family court of counting the same income stream twice in calculating support payments. The issue arises because New York, alone among the 50 states, treats enhanced income attributable to a professional license as community property and awards a share of it to the other spouse. The court may then proceed to assess child support payments on top of that against a non-custodial spouse. In doing so, however, courts have been basing child support formulas on the full professional income stream, even though part of that stream is no longer available, having been awarded to the other spouse. “The immediate effect of the [new Court of Appeals] ruling is that an Albany, N.Y., physician must pay his ex-wife two-thirds of his net income, about $91,000 a year, since his child support calculation ignores the fact that she is already drawing from the value of his medical license.” According to the majority of justices, this result simply follows from the phrasing of the state’s child support statute, and the legislature in Albany is free to change it if it is unfair. Dissenting Justices Robert Smith and Susan Phillips Read, on the other hand, point out that the statute in question “expressly permits departure from its formula to avoid an ‘unjust or inappropriate’ result.” (John Caher, “N.Y. Panel Upholds Disputed Child Support Formula”, New York Law Journal, Jun. 14; Holterman v. Holterman opinion, Jun. 10).
The cop and the criminal defense attorney
Ferrell Hunter, a sheriff’s deputy in Tunica County, Mississippi, was a Stakhanovite arrester of motorists on DUI charges, hailed by the state chapter of Mothers Against Drunk Driving as the state’s top such enforcement officer. But something MADD did not realize was that Tunica County has had a peculiarly low rate of actual conviction for DUI defendants. It turned out that Hunter had an arrangement with former Oxford attorney Joe Gregory Stewart: Hunter would provide Stewart with the names of motorists he arrested, Stewart would approach them and sign them up as clients, Hunter would then fail to make court dates so that the charges would be dropped, and Stewart would kick him back $200 or $300 per case. Now Hunter will serve three years probation after pleading guilty to conspiracy to commit extortion, while Stewart was sentenced to three years probation, hit with a $20,000 fine and disbarred. (Andy Wise, “Former Tunica County Deputy Sentenced For Fixing DUI’s”, WREG, Mar. 10)(via Lori Patel).
Pediatric orthopedic surgeon driven out of spinal surgery
In the complicated surgery to correct scoliosis, screws and rods are inserted and bone added into the spine. The risk of nerve damage or paralysis is such that there is something called the Stagnara wake up test, whereby the patient is woken during surgery to ensure she can move her feet. In 1999, however, Joshua Terry was one of the unfortunate 0.1% who was paralyzed during surgery. And, according to the newspaper account, his lawyer, Jay Kelley, found four surgeons to testify against defendant Dr. Ernest Lindell that “paralysis was not a potential complication” from surgery on the spine to correct scoliosis. A Lucas County, Ohio jury awarded $8.4 million to Mr. Terry and another million to his parents. And Dr. Lindell will no longer perform spinal surgery. (“Paralyzed area man wins $10M judgment”, Toledo Blade, Jun. 16; P. Stagnara, et al., “Functional monitoring of spinal cord activity during spinal surgery”, Clin. Orthop., 1973; 93: 173?8).
EFF Ten-Most Wanted Patents List
The Electronic Frontier Foundation announces a contest to find and publicize–and challenge–illegitimate patents:
In order to qualify for our ten most-wanted list, a patent must be software or Internet-related and there must be a good reason to suspect that the patent claims are invalid. We’re especially interested in patents that target tools of free expression, such as streaming media, blogging tools, and voice over IP (VoIP) technology. Most importantly, the patent-holder must be aggressively enforcing its patent and suing (or threatening to sue) alleged infringers. We’re particularly interested in cases where the patent-holder is trying to force small businesses, individuals, nonprofits, and consumers to pay licensing fees. Deadline to enter is June 23.
“EFF staff attorney Jason Schultz, who heads the project, said he can’t wait to see what the contest turns up. ‘We have seen illegitimate patents asserted on such simple technologies as one-click online shopping, video streaming, and paying with credit cards online. When individuals and small businesses are faced with million-dollar legal demands, they have no choice but to capitulate and pay license fees. We aim to change that.'” (EFF press release, Jun. 10) (via Crouch).
Mistook dance floor for conference workshop
New Hampshire: “Attorney General Peter Heed resigned abruptly Tuesday because of an allegation of inappropriate conduct with a woman. Gov. Craig Benson said the alleged incident occurred at a conference last month in Bretton Woods on preventing sexual and domestic abuse. …WMUR-TV reported that the alleged incident occurred after hours on a dance floor.” (Kate McGann, “New Hampshire A.G. Heed resigns over misconduct allegation”, Boston Globe, Jun. 15).