No, the Constitution’s Article 4, Section 4 “Republican form of government” clause doesn’t forbid the voters of Colorado from enacting a ballot measure (the “Taxpayer Bill of Rights,” or TABOR) that bars representatives from raising taxes without permission of a popular plebiscite [Ilya Shapiro and Julio Colomba, Cato, SCOTUSBlog, earlier]
Bootleg cigarettes, Prohibition and the death of Eric Garner
Eric Garner, asphyxiated during his arrest on Staten Island, had been repeatedly picked up by the NYPD for the crime of selling loose cigarettes. Washington Examiner:
The crime of selling “loosies” was not considered a serious one in the past. Many corner stores in New York City once sold them quietly upon request. But former Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s cartoonish anti-tobacco crusade changed that and everything else. Smoking in public places was banned. Punitive taxes and a legal minimum price of $10.50 were imposed in an effort to push prices ever-upward, so that a brand-name pack of 20 cigarettes now costs as much as $14 in New York City.
As a result, the illicit sale of loose and untaxed cigarettes became more commonplace.
I noted at yesterday’s Repeal Day panel at Cato that according to figures last year, New York’s unusually high cigarette taxes had brought it an unusual distinction: an estimated 60 percent of consumption there is of smuggled or illegal cigarettes, much higher than any other state. Another way to think of it is that New York has moved closer to prohibition than to a legal market in tobacco. [earlier 2003 Cato study]
In his history of Prohibition, Last Call, Daniel Okrent cites (among many other law enforcement misadventures) the fatal shooting of Jacob Hanson, secretary of an Elks lodge in Niagara Falls, New York, in a confrontation with alcohol agents — though Hanson had a clean record and was not carrying alcohol. At the time, many saw Hanson’s death as reflecting poorly on the Prohibition regime generally. For some reason, though, Senator Rand Paul (R-Ky.) has drawn fire from some quarters for making a parallel observation about Garner’s death. [BBC; note however that while Garner’s frictions with the local NYPD seem to owe much to his repeated cigarette arrests, the proximate event leading to his arrest seems to have been his attempt to break up a fight]
Yale’s Stephen Carter: “On the opening day of law school, I always counsel my first-year students never to support a law they are not willing to kill to enforce.” [Bloomberg View via Ilya Somin]
“Operation Choke Point Hits Ammunition Company in Maryland”
“Fox Business Network’s John Stossel interviews US Consumer Coalition’s Brian Wise and Kat O’Connor, owner of TomKat Ammunition LLC, on the Justice Department’s Operation Choke Point.” The Gaithersburg-based ammo seller was cut off from credit card processing services and suspects that the federal Choke Point program was the reason. [cross-posted from Free State Notes; earlier on Operation Choke Point].
P.S. There are signs that House Republicans may move to rein in Operation Check Point. Let’s hope so. [USA Today/Fond du Lac Reporter; HalfWheel (cigar news and reviews)]
Update: court rules chimp not endowed with human rights
“A chimpanzee is not entitled to the same rights as people and does not have be freed from captivity by its owner, a US court has ruled. The appeals court in New York state said caged chimpanzee Tommy could not be recognized as a ‘legal person’ as it ‘cannot bear any legal duties'”. [BBC, earlier]
More: Adam Kolber, PrawfsBlawg, and comments (“speciesism”).
Expand pregnancy-bias law to include accommodation rights?
Young v. United Parcel Service, in the Supreme Court, which has been built up as a cause celebre, turns on whether the courts should feel free to re-interpret a 1978 federal law, the Pregnancy Discrimination Act, so as to include evolving ideas of a right to accommodation akin to the ADA. The alternative position is that if such a right to accommodation is now thought to be a good idea, advocates should get Congress to enact it into law explicitly. [Lyle Denniston and related SCOTUSBlog, USA Today, Bloomberg/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette with auto-play, The Economist]
Great moments in warnings
From the United Kingdom:
Big thanks to @BekoUK for the useful advice pic.twitter.com/skGeNiiqt5
— Katie Martin (@KMartUK) December 3, 2014
Medical roundup
- Furious over EEOC attack on wellness programs, CEOs threaten to suspend their support for ObamaCare [Reuters] Had it been common knowledge that CEOs covertly support ObamaCare, then? And isn’t the EEOC formally an independent agency not answerable to White House directives?
- If more editors handled situations this way, readers would think better of the press: Annalee Newitz of io9 offers “apology and analysis” for running tendentious, ill-reported article attacking animal-based research;
- Success of personal injury litigation is reshaping nursing home business in some states [WSJ]
- “With the Advent of Mandatory Paid Sick Leave in California, Here are a Few Sick Leave Excuses” [Coyote, related Massachusetts]
- Really, it’s not a shock-scandal that rules for human-subjects research might be written by actual scientists [Zachary Schrag, IRB Blog]
- In combating diseases of poverty, you’d think economic growth would top the list of remedies [Bryan Caplan]
- Judge slices $9 billion punitive Actos award against Takeda and Lilly by 99% [Bloomberg, earlier]
- “Grubergate, the Mini-Series” [Michael Cannon; more from Cannon on Supreme Court’s grant of certiorari in King v. Burwell ObamaCare case]
Grand jury declines to indict cop in Eric Garner death
Even when it’s all caught on video, in daylight, with witnesses. Even when the cop blatantly broke the NYPD’s very clear ban on chokeholds. Even when the victim was heard “gurgl[ing] that he could not breathe” and the cop was heard bantering afterward with colleagues.
The confrontation between officer Darren Wilson and Michael Brown in Ferguson, Mo. had several elements that worked to bolster Wilson’s defense, including evidence that Brown had assaulted Wilson in his car and contradictions in the testimony of eyewitnesses. By contrast, the case for a Staten Island grand jury to return at least some charge in the choking death of Eric Garner at the hands of officer Daniel Pantaleo would seem considerably stronger. (Garner had tried to break up a sidewalk fight before police intervened, then argued with police and was uncompliant when they intervened; in accounts after the death, police said he had frequently tangled with law enforcement because of his habit of hanging out on the sidewalk selling “loosies” — single cigarettes out of their packages, a tax violation.)
Some of yesterday’s Twitter discussion:
Is there anyone defending the Garner homicide non indictment? I don't see how it's not at least negligent homicide.
— tedfrank (@tedfrank) December 3, 2014
(This morning, New York Post columnist Bob McManus does defend it.)
“I cant breathe.” pic.twitter.com/eJvmhnSsSv
— Andrew Kirell (@AndrewKirell) December 3, 2014
Typically, the Twitter law degree crowd gets angry a lot – but my timeline is filled with apoplectic ACTUAL lawyers #EricGarner
— Keith K (@kkaplan) December 3, 2014
1928, NY Judge tells jury police can't just "shoot and kill any offender who may not yield to his command…" pic.twitter.com/Ic3hRHnbT2
— profloumoore (@loumoore12) December 3, 2014
.@JonathanBlitzer this morn had essential context for choke-hold accountability & SI police dept probs #EricGarner pic.twitter.com/DYAKoKkjl9
— Ali Gharib (@Ali_Gharib) December 3, 2014
Seeing lots of "Garner story shows cop cameras don't work" tweets. But transparency isn't meant to be a solution. Just exposes the problem.
— Radley Balko (@radleybalko) December 3, 2014
Be skeptical of "untaxed cigarettes" myth. Didn't appear until day after death, when it suddenly b/c part of narrative. Unmentioned at 1st.
— Scott Greenfield (@ScottGreenfield) December 3, 2014
Pass a law against something very petty – realize that it will be enforced with LETHAL FORCE against someone who persistently violates it.
— Arthur Kimes (@ComradeArthur) December 3, 2014
In satire, truth. RT @theonion Obama Calls For Turret-Mounted Video Cameras On All Police Tanks http://t.co/WRfdwG0rEi #EricGarner
— Walter Olson (@walterolson) December 3, 2014
By the way: the guy who recorded the video of Eric Garner being murdered? HE was indicted. Of course. http://t.co/fpLIc1se7q
— Christopher Bowen (@superbus) December 3, 2014
MT @familylawcourts Maybe we need to stop electing people who boast a law enforcement endorsement.#EricGarner #BlackLivesMatter
— Walter Olson (@walterolson) December 3, 2014
modest proposal: when there is a civilian death at the hands of law enforcement, a public defender is named to be the special prosecutor
— Chris Tolles (@tolles) December 3, 2014
Maybe we need to stop giving police unions a political veto over police reform ideas [my @CatoInstitute yesterday] http://t.co/jyEcvNbhXx
— Walter Olson (@walterolson) December 3, 2014
Frustrated by Grand Juries? Read this 2003 Cato paper by W. Thomas Dillard, Stephen Ross Johnson, and Timothy Lynch: http://t.co/zFOGr8J9Ke
— Matt Welch (@MattWelch) December 4, 2014
“The Cult of Kiddie Danger”
Today it is a sin — and sometimes a crime — NOT to imagine your children dead the moment we take your eyes off them. The moment they skip to school with a Chapstick, wait in the car a minute, or play at the park.
We think we are enlightened in this quest to keep kids completely safe. Actually, we have entered a new Dark Ages, fearing evil all around us.
If we want the right to raise our kids rationally, even optimistically, it’s time to call the Cult of Kiddie Danger what it is: mass hysteria aided and abetted by the authorities. But as earlier holy books so succinctly instructed us, there is a better way to live.
“Fear not.”
Duluth library seed-sharing program may violate state law
The library in Duluth, Minn. may need to discontinue its seed sharing program, popular among local gardeners. “State agriculture regulators say the exchange — one of about 300 in the United States — violates the state’s seed law because it does not test seeds. … ‘The last thing you’d want to have is somebody goes in the library, picks up seed, and it doesn’t come up,” said Steve Malone, a supervisor in the department’s Plant Protection Division.'” That would be anarchy! [Minnesota Public Radio]