Overlawyered: Chronicling The High Cost Of Our Legal System

Posts Tagged ‘politics’

Pennsylvania Reform Roadblocked

Doctors in Pennsylvania had high hopes for the possibility of caps on non-economic damages in their state. They had managed to get a bill for an amendment to the state constitution that would allow the caps, only to see it killed in committee by opponents of tort reform. Evidently, the legislators don’t want to take the issue to the people, who would have had to vote on the amendment. Will they be willing to answer to the consequences of their inaction? Young doctors already view Pennsylvania as a state to avoid :

In 2003, only 17% of residents who trained in Pennsylvania stayed there, according to the Pennsylvania Medical Society. The state had a net loss of 507 physicians from 2002 to 2003, and it dropped into the bottom 10 states for the number of young physicians in the state, PMS data show.

Filed under: ,

Welcome New York Times (and Wonkette) readers

Yesterday John Tierney in the New York Times quoted me calculating that the $2.4 million that the Democrats paid for general liability insurance for their four-day convention amounted to roughly $500 per delegate/alternate, or about $120 per day apiece. My suggested line for Sen. John Edwards’s acceptance speech: “I’m worth it.” (John Tierney and Sheryl Gay Stolberg, “Rehabilitating the L-Word”, New York Times, Jul. 29). For more on the Democrats’ insurance bill (they paid an extra $86,000, on top of the $2.4 million, to add terrorism coverage), see “Democrats’ Insurance Coverage To Top $2.6m For Convention”, Bestwire (A.M. Best & Co.), Jul. 12.

Also welcome to readers of Wonkette, which picked up the item (Jul. 29). I should point out, however, that contrary to the site’s description of me I’m not a lawyer.

Filed under: ,

Pro bono: being fair to Edwards

A Washington Times editorial asserts that John Edwards during his career as a plaintiff’s lawyer “took no pro bono cases”, which if true might expose him to obloquy and also could put him into conflict with the ABA’s Model Rule on the subject (“The science of malpractice”, Jul. 25; see KipEsquire, Jul. 25). Tucker Carlson voiced the same charge on CNN “Crossfire” Jan. 12 (transcript).
But is the charge accurate? In a quick search on “John Edwards” + “pro bono”, the most prominent article to turn up is Adam Liptak’s Jul. 14 New York Times piece, “Edwards’s Lawyerly Style Drew Fierce Foes and Fans”, which phrases things rather differently: “Mr. Edwards handled no notable pro bono cases, the typical vehicle for lawyers who want to have a larger impact.” (emphasis added). The difference is potentially significant, since an attorney might devote considerable effort to pro bono work without handling any court cases that his colleagues might recognize as notable (say, because they sought to shape the course of the law).

No doubt we’ll be hearing more about the nature and scope of Edwards’ pro bono efforts as the campaign proceeds. In the mean time, those of us who are skeptical of his candidacy should be careful not to let our criticisms run ahead of the available evidence.

Filed under: , ,

In the Kerry skyboxes

Unlike his running mate John Edwards, John Kerry has willingly disclosed the identities of his “bundlers”, the financiers responsible for raising large amounts of money in grouped donations. (He has 266 who’ve come in at the $100,000+ level, compared with more than 525 for George W. Bush.) Names familiar to readers of this site are well represented: “Trial lawyers who represent injured people in suits against business are prominent Kerry fans. Among his $100,000 Vice Chairmen are Florida plaintiff’s lawyer Kirk Wager, who hosted Mr. Kerry’s first presidential fund-raiser at his Coconut Grove home in December 2002, and attorneys Richard Scruggs of Mississippi and John Coale of Washington, both part of the tobacco companies’ $206 billion settlement with 46 states.” However, Mr. Kerry (like Mr. Bush, but unlike Mr. Edwards) also raises large amounts from other types of law firms, including firms known for lobbying and for general business work, including Mintz Levin and Piper Rudnick. (Wayne Slater, “Vested interests in Kerry”, Dallas Morning News, Jul. 25).

“Lawyers, especially trial lawyers, are the engine of the Kerry fundraising operation,” reports the Washington Post. “Lawyers and law firms have given more money to Kerry, $12 million, than any other sector. One out of four of Kerry’s big-dollar fundraisers is a lawyer, and one out of 10 is an attorney for plaintiffs in personal injury, medical malpractice or other lawsuits seeking damages. …

“Among the trial lawyers who raised money for Kerry early in the campaign were Michael V. Ciresi of Robins, Kaplan, Miller & Ciresi LLP, who represented Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Minnesota in its successful $6.5 billion suit against the tobacco industry, and Michael T. Thorsnes, who recently retired from his San Diego law firm after winning $250 million in settlements and verdicts.” After Kerry locked up the race, “One trend was a sharp increase in the number of trial lawyers joining the Kerry fundraising campaign. Among those soon joining as major fundraisers were John P. Coale, one of the nation’s most prominent trial lawyers, whose better-known cases include the Union Carbide disaster in Bhopal, India, and at least 16 plane crashes; Robert L. Lieff, founding partner of Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein LLP, a San Francisco-based firm that lists four class-action settlements in 2004 alone totaling $176.5 million; and San Francisco lawyer Arnold Laub, whose firm Web site lists its participation in the $3.7 billion fen-phen settlement, a $185 million toxic chemical award and $4.5 million for a pedestrian accident case. … John Morgan, an Orlando lawyer whose firm specializes in medical malpractice, said he has helped raise more than $500,000 for Kerry.” (Thomas B. Edsall, James V. Grimaldi and Alice R. Crites, “Redefining Democratic Fundraising”, Washington Post, Jul. 24)(our politics archive).

Filed under: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Calif. state senator Joe Dunn

He made a fortune suing doctors, then moved up to the California State Senate as a Democrat representing Orange County communities including Anaheim, Santa Ana, Fullerton and Garden Grove. Now he’s one of the chief guardians of trial lawyer interests in Sacramento. Will he run for state attorney general in 2006? (Michael A. Glueck, “The runaway trial lawyer”, Jewish World Review, Jul. 9). Dunn was chief sponsor of the first-in-the-nation bill signed into law by Gov. Gray Davis last year, authorizing lawyers to file private damage suits over labor code violations; see Oct. 20.

Filed under: ,

Initiative battles

In Florida, the state supreme court has certified for the fall ballot a doctor-backed initiative (see Mar. 1) that would cut lawyers’ fees in malpractice cases, and also three lawyer-backed “revenge” initiatives aimed at the doctors. And in Colorado, a proposed amendment is headed for the ballot that would write into the state constitution broad rights to sue over construction defects. Major battles are expected on both — details at Point Of Law (Fla., Colo.).

Filed under: , ,

The men behind Edwards

I’ve got an op-ed in today’s Wall Street Journal arguing that the scariest thing about John Edwards (see Feb. 19 and many other links on this site) is the “tightly organized fund-raising and electoral machine” he has constructed most of whose key backers “are drawn from the tiny handful of tort lawyers even more successful than he”. In particular, four of the most powerful men behind Edwards — Fred Baron, John O’Quinn, Tab Turner, and Paul Minor — personify in various ways some of the most objectionable features of today’s personal-injury litigation scene. (Walter Olson, “Edwards & Co.”, Jul. 12, paid subscribers only)(free OpinionJournal.com version).

Filed under: , , , , , ,